Return to Forensic Home Page

Landmark Cases

Case Name: In re Subpoena on Jorge ZUNIGA, M.D., & Gary PIERCE, M.D.

Date, Location, Cite: 1983 MI
714 Fed R 2d 553
US Court of Appeals, 6th Circuit

Zuniga & Pierce, separately, refused Federal subpoenas duces tecum for investigation of Medicaid/Blue Cross fraud. subpoena's asked for names, dates, services to compare to records. Cases heard together, Court said these data did not fall in dr-patient privilege, this request did not violate right to privacy, 5th Amendment didn't count here because they were professional corporations, not individuals. Federal Court doesn't have any blanket privilege for Dr.
cf Commonwealth v Kobrin